Students appreciate smart locks, as long as they open

Smart locks are increasingly leaving students locked out of their homes. In several cities, this has sparked debate and, in Twente, even led to a court case. Students in Eindhoven mainly see the benefits of smart locks, provided the systems work as intended.

More and more student housing complexes are getting smart locks. This means residents no longer need a physical key. Instead, they can use an app on their phones to enter their homes. In Utrecht, residents of student housing provider SSH regularly find themselves locked out because their phones have run out of battery or because of malfunctions in the locking system.

In Twente, students are opposing plans by housing provider Veste Wonen to install smart locks in nearly 3,000 homes on the university campus. Veste Wonen is not allowed to install the locks without residents' consent. The matter is now before the courts.

Cursor asked its Instagram followers whether they have a smart lock and what their experiences with such systems are. Of the 147 respondents, 20 percent said they have one in their homes. Smart lock systems are used, among other places, in the three residential towers on campus and in several other student housing complexes across the city.

Convenience

For many students, the main advantage of smart locks is convenience. They no longer have to carry a physical key and can use their phones to enter their homes. Students who regularly lose their keys see this as a welcome solution.

I definitely wouldn't be happy if the phone were my only option, since my battery runs out quickly

Alexander Hristov
Master's student Mechanical Engineering

Still, many students don't want to rely entirely on their phones. They particularly appreciate having both a physical NFC tag and an app. “It's convenient because I always have my keys with me on my phone, but I also have a physical key,” says master's student Alexander Hristov (Mechanical Engineering). “I definitely wouldn't be happy if I only had the phone option, because the battery runs out quickly. I don't want to rely on it for something as important as getting into my home.”

This is an important difference compared to students in Utrecht, where student housing provider SSH only offers an app as a digital key. Students can purchase a physical key as an alternative, but it costs 200 euros.

Other students particularly appreciate being able to use a single digital key to access different areas of their building. They can use it not only to open the front door, but also their room and mailbox, for example. “At first, I was skeptical because I wondered whether the lock would still work if the power or internet went out, and whether I would end up locked out,” says Konstantinos Kyratsopoulos (Electrical Engineering). “It turns out that it works just fine without either.”

Sharing keys

At the same time, digital keys also come with limitations. Although this may vary depending on the housing provider, it is generally not possible to share a key with friends or family.

“You can only have one phone connected to the lock system and only one key,” says student Psychology and Technology Sarah-Maaike van Bentum. “This means you can't leave a spare key with your neighbors in case you accidentally lock yourself out with your phone and key inside.”

Not always reliable

Being locked out can also be costly for students. On campus, a replacement tag costs at least 30 euros. Students say they have to pay considerably more if they lose their key on weekends or during holidays. Calling a technician to open the front door can also be expensive: depending on the time and day, the cost can reach 170 euros.

It just wouldn't open for about an hour

Ivan Sakal
Fontys student

The system itself does not always work smoothly, either. Student Ivan Sakal is pursuing a master's degree in Applied ICT at Fontys. He previously lived at Lombokpad and in one of the residential towers at the Blauwe Loper. He recalls that the locks sometimes failed to work. “It just wouldn't open for about an hour. I then had to call the company that supplied the lock.”

Automotive Technology student Willemijn Verschuur was initially positive about her smart lock, but says the system has become outdated after five years and is increasingly prone to connection problems. She does not have a physical tag. “In that case, I have to call the lock manager to get the door opened. That could be a problem if I get home very late. Fortunately, I haven't experienced that yet.”

This article was translated using AI-assisted tools and reviewed by an editor

Share this article