
Board, council and unions dare to disagree again
“We didn’t need a formal procedure, but a conversation”
For months, the Executive Board, University Council and trade unions have been working to rebuild trust among themselves. Last week, a report on this joint process was published. The process took place behind closed doors, leaving the TU/e community in the dark for a long time about what was happening: “Confidentiality was necessary.”
Trust between the governing bodies has grown, according to the parties involved, but it still appears fragile. The report published on Monday last week, for which research agency Verinorm investigated two cases involving social safety and held two dialogue sessions with the Executive Board (CvB), the University Council (UR) and the trade unions, shows that there is still work to be done. Both the CvB and the UR received a number of recommendations aimed at improving their working relationships.
It is clear that all parties involved are willing to take the agency’s recommendations seriously. The CvB, for example, has already promised to be less quick to resort to legal action and to become more aware of power imbalances.
“We have been tough on ourselves in our rather critical reflection,” says Koen Janssen, President of the Executive Board. “But I believe that is the only way to rebuild trust.” By acknowledging past mistakes, the CvB is responding to a request from the UR and the trade unions.
Entrenched attitudes
The investigation reveals that there were significant problems in the cooperation between the three bodies. Janssen recognizes this picture from when he took over as President of the Executive Board a year and a half ago. “I found relations between the various governing bodies to be entrenched.”
According to him, the two cases investigated were at the root of this deterioration. “We made a major effort to improve the situation. That meant we had to examine those cases to understand what had happened during the process and what we could learn from it.”
What was originally intended to be an investigation into the roles played by the parties involved in the two cases and how they had handled them gradually evolved into a confidential process focused on rebuilding trust.
According to Jan Vleeshouwers of the FNV trade union, the reason for this change was that what was needed turned out not to be a formal procedure, but a conversation. However, the confidentiality of the process meant that the university community remained in the dark for a long time about what was happening behind closed doors.
A confidential setting
Nevertheless, all parties support the way the process was handled, as they believe the conversations would not otherwise have been possible. “If we had done this in public, it would have turned into more of a debate in which we would be defending positions, rather than taking the time to understand each other’s perspectives,” Janssen says. “This needed to happen in a confidential setting, even though I understand that these are matters that concern the entire community.”
University Council member Hjalmar Mulders agrees. “But we are also saying that we are not done yet. A public document will now be published, setting out how we will follow up on the recommendations. The UR and the unions will be keeping a close eye on that.”
Taking an active critical role
“It’s not just about keeping a critical eye on things, but also about actively contributing in a critical way,” Janssen responds. The Council itself also received a number of recommendations. According to Mulders, its members have already started working on them, despite having some reservations about the origins of certain conclusions.
Verinorm’s recommendations are largely aimed at improving relations between the various governing bodies. According to the agency, the biggest challenge is not improving rules and procedures, but changing how people deal with them.
Teun Jongmans, who serves on the UR as a student member, says it is an illusion to think that everything can be laid down in guidelines and rules. “The attitude you adopt when working within those rules or guidelines is, of course, entirely open to interpretation. So you have to find an approach that is constructive and helps move the university forward.”
Keeping a closer eye on things
The President of the Executive Board wants to address this by taking a more hands-on approach. Members of the CvB will therefore visit UR subcommittees more frequently. “I now do this every month,” Janssen explains. “We talk in a confidential setting about what we see, tackle issues head-on and discuss them.”
The formal University Council meeting now also includes a closed session to make the same kind of discussions possible. “When you talk to each other in a trusted setting, you can share more and address patterns within the organization. But that really does need to happen in confidence. That is a prerequisite for me,” Janssen says.
According to him, both ombuds officers will also meet regularly with the UR and the trade unions. Janssen says these measures should lead to more frequent dialogue, so that discussions do not take place only at the last minute.
Behind closed doors
As with the Verinorm process, these measures mean that a considerable part of the discussions will take place in confidential settings. According to Vleeshouwers of the trade union, the contradiction is that more matters are being discussed behind closed doors, while the university community wants to know what is going on.
“We still need to find a proper balance, because there is certainly a desire, particularly from the perspective of participation body, for things to happen in public,” Vleeshouwers says. “However, many discussions of this kind do not start in public. You cannot have them in an open setting either, but ultimately the results must be visible in a public context.”
Janssen agrees. “I think you should always be clear about the process you are going through. You can be transparent about that without disclosing every detail.”
Frank discussions
According to Mulders, the UR now recognizes that, in order to make a meaningful contribution, it is sometimes necessary to have confidential conversations at an earlier stage. He says that discussions between the parties can now be quite frank.
“Even when we disagree, we dare to say so, and we can then continue the conversation without slamming the door shut. I think that should be seen as a major step forward.”
“By no means have all the problems been solved,” Mulders says. “But at least we can now work on them.”
Ombuds
In addition to the two cases investigated by Verinorm, the role of former ombuds officer Anna Soedira also had a major impact on relations between the CvB, the UR and the trade unions. Shortly before Soedira stepped down prematurely, the trade unions had already published a joint statement expressing concern that the CvB had effectively sidelined the ombuds officer because of a lack of trust.
Meanwhile, a conflict had also arisen between Soedira and the CvB over confidential communications involving the ombuds officer that the CvB had allegedly introduced as evidence in two cases. Verinorm’s investigation was intended to establish how this had happened and clarify, among other things, the role of the ombuds officer.
In its own reflection, the CvB promised not to introduce ombuds communications in cases anymore and to seek an external assessment first in exceptional circumstances. It also promised to clarify the division of responsibilities more explicitly, together with the UR and the Supervisory Board.
Personal attack
Vleeshouwers sees the conflict surrounding the ombuds officer as a major source of the entrenched relations between the governing bodies. “We had been advocating for an ombuds function at universities for a long time. When it was finally established, we thought: okay, we’ve reached our goal.”
However, the unions noticed that in many parts of the organization, statements made by the ombuds officer were seen as personal attacks rather than as a neutral means of support. According to Vleeshouwers, unusual expectations arose about what an ombuds officer was supposed to do, could do and was allowed to do. “At certain points, things got completely out of hand. From our perspective, that was a major mistake.”
A new player
Mulders recognizes what Vleeshouwers is saying and, looking back, does not find the outcome surprising. “This is a new kind of player, one who also has influence or power. That means the existing structure has to adapt to some extent. Organizational changes always meet with resistance.”
In hindsight, it is not surprising that things turned out this way, Vleeshouwers says. “But of course, it is unfortunate.” Janssen agrees. “It is certainly not something anyone wants.” However, he sees it as part of a much broader issue.
“We are now putting a strong emphasis on leadership. That is fundamental to supporting people, but also to ensuring social safety.” He also believes it is important for people to be able to engage in balanced dialogue with one another and learn how to give and receive feedback.
Accepting criticism
“The ombuds officer also provided feedback,” Vleeshouwers adds. “Exactly,” Janssen says. “And one thing you sometimes see when it comes to feedback is that people experience it as: I feel unsafe because someone is criticizing me.”
“To be honest, I think that goes too far. So we need to teach people throughout the organization to engage in dialogue with one another, including about critical issues, without damaging their relationships.” According to him, everyone has a role to play in this, “but we need to be able to move forward together, which is why we are taking a systemic approach.”
In its report, Verinorm states that greater clarity is needed about the different roles within the university. According to Janssen, these roles are already well defined, but they have been interpreted differently than expected in practice, including in the case of the ombuds officer.
Challenges in defining roles
The UR and the CvB are working to clarify the various roles, but Vleeshouwers from the union believes some ambiguity will always remain. “You also need to be flexible enough to deal with all kinds of situations where roles overlap or become unclear.”
And how should they do that? “That requires a certain degree of sensitivity. If you don't have it, you need to develop it.”
Discussion