Knowledge security: fewer fields and no student screening

The government needs to take a more targeted approach to protecting sensitive knowledge, says Minister Letschert. Students may not need to be screened, and she is also considering classifying fewer fields as “sensitive.”

by
photo Rijksoverheid / Martijn Beekman

Dutch universities have a wealth of knowledge that is also of interest to other countries. This comes with risks: some countries go to great lengths to steal this knowledge to strengthen their own regimes.

In 2022, then-Minister of Education Robbert Dijkgraaf therefore announced plans to screen researchers and master's students working in “sensitive” fields. The proposal sparked widespread criticism, particularly among universities. They feared it would make the Netherlands less attractive to international talent.

However, a screening law with such a broad scope is “not feasible,” Minister Rianne Letschert wrote in a letter to the House of Representatives in early June. She is now proposing an alternative: a “narrower” screening process. She will investigate whether this approach is feasible.

Making choices

A more limited screening process will require some choices, the minister says. The list of sensitive technologies will have to be shortened. She cannot yet say which fields will remain on the list.

She also wants to screen fewer people. Under the earlier proposal, master's students would be screened alongside researchers. The minister is considering exempting students and focusing exclusively on researchers.

Letschert also wants to prevent stricter rules from being imposed on higher education institutions than on companies. There must be “a level playing field,” the minister believes. After all, businesses also have access to a great deal of sensitive knowledge. She wants to ensure that the regulations of the Ministry of Education, Culture and Science (OCW) and the Ministry of Economic Affairs are aligned.

Significant costs

In their response, universities write that they, too, recognize the importance of knowledge security. Despite budget cuts, universities have made substantial investments in protecting sensitive knowledge, they emphasize.

However, not all universities face the same level of risk, says umbrella organization Universities of the Netherlands (UNL). They should not all be treated alike. The organization also points to the significant costs associated with knowledge security.

Above all, universities want to avoid being subjected to strict regulations that cannot be implemented in practice. They would rather take responsibility for protecting their knowledge themselves.

At the same time, they are calling for greater clarity on so-called dual-use research: research that can be used for both civilian and military purposes. One example is the development of drone technology.

The Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW) and research funding organization NWO have responded positively to the minister's intention to narrow the scope of the screening process. However, both continue to highlight the risks to academic freedom. They also warn that the screening process could inadvertently lead to discrimination.

Other options

In addition to a narrower screening process, the minister is exploring other options. One possibility is to require knowledge institutions to establish their own access policies, rather than having the national government conduct the screening. However, this option also requires further investigation.

Letschert hopes to inform the House of Representatives about the feasibility of a more limited screening process in the spring of 2027. A total of 100 million euros has been allocated to safeguard knowledge security.

This article was translated using AI-assisted tools and reviewed by an editor.

Share this article