TU/e splits PhD contracts: first temporary contract

Instead of immediately receiving a four-year contract, new PhD candidates will initially be offered an 18-month temporary contract starting next academic year. They will only be allowed to continue their PhD research if they receive a “go” after the first year. According to the university, however, the aim remains to enable PhD candidates to complete the full program.

by
photo Vincent van den Hoogen

The new contract structure makes it easier for TU/e to part ways at an earlier stage with PhD candidates who are underperforming or have a low likelihood of successfully completing their PhD.

Under both the new and the current arrangements, PhD candidates who receive a negative assessment in their first year must first follow an improvement plan. Under the current system, this takes place after nine months; under the new contracts, it will take place after one year. The main difference lies in what happens next. 

According to Human Resources Management (HRM), with a four-year contract insufficient improvement may ultimately result in either a settlement agreement or a request for termination through legal proceedings. An 18-month temporary contract, on the other hand, simply will not be renewed in that situation.

Financial burden

According to HRM, the change is desirable because, under the current system, improvement plans often lead to long-term sick leave, workplace conflicts, and legal proceedings. The department also states in a memo outlining the plan that this creates “significant organizational and financial burden on the university” and causes uncertainty for both PhD candidates and their supervisors.

Since the collective labor agreement allows universities to initially offer an 18-month temporary contract, and the vast majority of universities already use this type of contract, HRM considers it a suitable option for TU/e as well. The Executive Board agrees and approved the plan on Thursday. The aim is to introduce the temporary contracts starting next academic year.

Escalation

To support its proposal, HRM provides several figures. For example, of the average total of 375 PhD candidates per year, an average of 30 received a negative assessment after their first year in both 2024 and 2025.

Of those who received a negative assessment, 25 percent successfully completed the improvement plan and were able to continue their PhD research. Nearly 50 percent of all negative assessments reportedly resulted in escalation, such as long-term sick leave and legal proceedings.

Sick leave

According to HRM, there is no known research showing that temporary contracts have a negative impact on the well-being of PhD candidates. HRM also argues that the fact that long-term absence already occurs during the first or second year demonstrates that the length of the contract is not, in itself, a protective factor.

According to the department, long-term absence represents a major expense. Combined with other lengthy procedures, it can continue to drain project budgets, leaving less money available for alternative research. The temporary contracts would provide greater flexibility to deploy the remaining funds for alternative research capacity, the memo states.

The document emphasizes that the primary goal remains to support PhD candidates in successfully completing their doctoral research on time. The new contract structure should be seen as “part of a broader commitment to strengthening the overall PhD journey.” According to HRM, the new arrangement provides greater clarity and certainty for everyone involved.

PhD Council and trade unions

Lucia Švandová, who represents Applied Physics and Science Education on the university's PhD Council, says the council understands the reasoning behind the change. However, when it comes to the consequences for PhD candidates, she says the main concern is that the new arrangement will increase the pressure surrounding the go/no-go assessment. “That is why it is important to keep this process, which is now being redesign as part of the New PhD Strategy, fair and unified throughout the university. Overall we believe that this change will help identify problems early on in the PhD program.”

The trade unions are critical of the plan. They, too, fear that the initial period will become even more stressful for PhD candidates, who are already in a vulnerable position. The unions believe it is essential that the criteria against which PhD candidates will be assessed after 18 months are clear from the very start of their contracts.

This article was translated using AI-assisted tools and reviewed by an editor.

Share this article