Ideals
TU/e should take a hard look at its ideals, argues Boudewijn van Dongen. Because grand ambitions can turn into major obstacles in a new reality.
Back in the 1960s, my namesake, Dutch singer-songwriter Boudewijn de Groot, sang about ideals, as he drew up the testament of his youth. “Anyone who wants them can come and get them; young people, in particular, still like them.” What the singer was trying to say, is that holding on to ideals becomes impossible as you grow older.
TU/e, too, now that it has turned 70 and is well past its childhood years, is full of ideals. And here, too, it is gradually becoming impossible to hold on to all of them when confronted with the realities of everyday life.
Take challenge-based education, for example. This educational approach is based on the ideal of an instructor acting as a mentor to a small group of students.
It is also an approach that does not fit the scale at which some TU/e degree programs are expected to operate in an era when generative AI is everywhere. That MIT can make it work, is hardly surprising: its budget per student is about 15 times higher than ours.
Or consider our carefully designed recruitment process. Having a single applicant evaluated by an appointment advisory committee costs an estimated €5,000 to €6,000 in staff hours for everyone involved.
If, as part of the Beethoven program, you have more than 30 vacancies to fill and interview several applicants for each position, you will already have spent several hundred thousand euros before your new colleagues have even taught a single class.
And there are plenty of other examples: scheduling in time slots, the quarter-based academic calendar, interdisciplinary graduation projects, centrally imposed model regulations, 40-hour timesheets, and accommodating all kinds of exceptional exam arrangements.
All of these are examples of policies that make sense from an idealistic point of view, but that have also been overtaken by the times we live in. Under pressure from budget cuts, we now have to guide large numbers of students through their degree programs as quickly as possible.
Perhaps it is time for TU/e to take a critical look at all these policies and make different choices. And our ideals? They will become fond memories of our youth: we carry them with us for as long as we live.
The song Testament by Boudewijn de Groot can be listened to here.
Boudewijn van Dongen is a full professor of Process Analytics at TU/e. The views expressed in this column are his own. This column was translated using AI-assisted tools and reviewed by the author and an editor.

Discussion